Published in the December 14 – 27, 2016 issue of Gilroy Life
By Marty Cheek

Marty Cheek
The Oxford English Dictionary announced its word of the year as “post-truth.” I thought it was an apt choice for America and Britain in 2016 when the political environment saw divisive, populist upheavals where people seemed to prize feelings more than facts.
The OED defined “post-truth” as “relating to or denoting circumstances in which objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief.” The origin of the word goes back to 1992. Its use exploded by 2,000 percent in 2016 compared to the previous year, according to OED officials who monitor use of the English language.
Two news stories proved that “post-truth” is the word reflecting recent political and social discourse. The Brexit vote showed how many of the British people were willing to blindly follow their passions even in the face of out-right lies told by politicians. And the most contentious presidential election in American history featured the campaigns of two of the least trusted candidates, according to polls. It’s no coincidence this “post-truth” year also saw the rise of social media as a news source and a growing distrust of facts offered by the traditional news establishment.
This summer as the election season ramped up, I had an interesting conversation with a South Valley woman where we debated the idea that feelings should be just as valid as facts for voters. Coming from a journalism background, I made the comment that the media no longer adequately fact-checks candidates’ statements on the campaign trail. This failure in vetting what candidates say is a disservice to democracy, I pointed out. Voters knowing what is true and what is false is vital in making decisions.
She disagreed. Facts, she said, don’t really matter anymore. How someone “feels” what is true and what is false is just as important — and maybe even more so — in deciding the value of what a politician says.
It was a frustrating conversation for both of us. I kept insisting that objective facts should be more relevant than how a person might feel, a subjective interpretation of a situation. And she kept insisting that facts don’t matter. How a person feels is just as valid as the facts, even if those feelings go against the facts.
This post-truth world we’re now entering is a scary one. This is how dictators rise through demagoguery to seize power. It’s a danger to American democracy. Maybe, unfortunately, it’s a “1984” world we’re now allowing our republic to pass into. The British writer George Orwell’s famous novel warned how easily we might lose our freedoms when a society willingly becomes disconnected from the details of honest discourse through the manipulation of the media. We saw it this year in the repetitive assertions of false talking points in which factual rebuttals are ignored or even mocked.
In this brave new world of post-truth politics, campaigners keep repeating their talking points, even if these points are proven to be untrue by the media or by independent experts. During the election this summer for the British European Union referendum campaign that resulted in Brexit, the political organization Vote Leave kept drumming its claim that EU membership cost Britain’s taxpayers £350 million a week.
This much-publicized figure ignored the UK rebate and other factors. The UK Statistics Authority called the figure “potentially misleading.” The Institute for Fiscal Studies called it “not sensible.” It was rejected in fact-checking done by BBC News, Channel 4 News and Full Fact. This falsity of the figure was broadcast by the media to the British public, but despite the vetting, Vote Leave continued to push the figure as a centerpiece of its campaign until the day of the referendum — advertising it on billboards and websites and even sending a coach bus around the country with the slogan on the side: “We send the EU $350 million a week. Let’s fund our NHS (National Health Service) instead. Vote Leave.” After the election where 52 percent of voting British citizens decided to leave the European Union, supporters of Brexit had to quickly back-track on the untrue promises they made that the money would go to the NHS.
Feelings are an important part of what make us human. But feelings can be easily manipulated. Politicians know this and often use cunningly disingenuous slogans and advertising. In a post-truth world, facts lose out to feelings. And that simple fact might mean the death of our American democracy.
