Published in the September 7 – 20, 2016 issue of Gilroy Life

By Mark Turner

Mark Turner

Mark Turner

As Election Day draws near, there is a lot of misinformation floating around with regard to Measure H, the Urban Growth Boundary Initiative, which will be on the ballot in November. It’s important to understand the negative impacts Measure H will have on Gilroy. This initiative is a 22-year-long commitment. Residents don’t want to find themselves in a situation of, “having to vote for Measure H to learn what’s in Measure H.” Voters can change the make-up of the City Council every two years. That’s where the people’s accountability needs to exist. Ballot box land planning has never proven to be a successful approach for a community, however, the proponents of Measure H would have you believe it works, at least that’s what they say.

1. They say, “Measure H will give you, the voter, the right to decide critical growth decision affecting Gilroy.”

FACT: Fewer individuals are actually voting each election cycle. This November there will be 17 state initiatives on the ballot not to mention the county’s billion-dollar housing initiative, the transportation tax, regional elections, school board and council elections. The massive amount of information can be overwhelming and time consuming. If voters are unable to do the proper research on certain issues, should the outcome be left to special interests? Vote NO on Measure H and keep accountability where it should be.

2. They say, “It’s simple. Measure H will give our citizens the power to decide how large our city will grow in the future.”

FACT: LAFCO (Local Agency Formation Commission) determines how large our city will grow, not voters. Since 2010, LAFCO has allowed no more than 10 acres to be annexed by Morgan Hill and has allowed no land to be annexed in Gilroy. LAFCO recently rejected efforts by the Diocese to build a Catholic high school in Morgan Hill. Aside from LAFCO, our city has the second strongest growth controls in the county. Do we really need a third layer of bureaucracy? Vote NO on Measure H to avoid more government intrusion.

3. They say, “Measure H maintains Gilroy’s small-town character and that we have enough land within the UGB to accommodate needed housing and job growth through 2040.”

FACT: They fail to tell you implementing the UGB will result in a decline of more than 45 percent of potential new jobs, labor income and economic output. The few jobs produced will be mostly minimum wage jobs in the area of retail, restaurant and entertainment, not living wage jobs. It will also eliminate nearly eight million square feet of industrial land for future business development where higher income jobs are created. Fewer jobs and less housing will drastically reduce revenue needed by the city to maintain streets, roads, parks and public safety. Vote NO on Measure H to keep Gilroy moving forward.

4. The say, “Outward-sprawling development will make our traffic worse.”

FACT: With fewer jobs available in Gilroy, more residents will be required to travel north to find work. The independent 9212 report indicates the implementation of Measure H will likely increase vehicle miles traveled. Portland, Oregon’s UGB, often touted by UGB advocates as being a success, has created worsening traffic issues. Travel times inside and outside Portland’s UGB area have continually increased. U.S. data shows that traffic congestion is less where urban areas are less dense. Implementation of Gilroy’s Measure H would reduce roadway extensions or improvements that would be needed outside the proposed UGB. Vote NO on Measure H and avoid traffic congestion.

5. They say, “Measure H will direct future development closer to existing city services and infrastructure. This will save Gilroy money and encourage investment in our downtown.”

FACT: They fail to remind you the cost of new housing development infrastructure (local streets, curbs, sidewalks, storm and waste sewers, and water supply lines within the development) is paid for privately by the builder and passed on to the buyers. These are fully private costs that are paid for by persons who voluntarily move into new houses and apartments, having determined that they can afford such a move. Vote NO on Measure H for freedom of choice.

6. They say, “Measure H draws a line on sprawl to protect the remaining natural open space and farmland surrounding Gilroy for future generations.”

FACT: Nearly all of the UGB advocates promoting Measure H live in single family homes with a front and back yard. Some have sprawling properties of their own. They live on what was once considered farmland and open space. Some of those advocates have only been in Gilroy a few years. Now that they have theirs, it’s time to force new residents into condensed housing with a 32 square foot balcony. Vote NO on Measure H because people should have the right to live and work where and how they like.

Mark Turner is the president and CEO of the Gilroy Chamber of Commerce.