Published in the July 27-August 10, 2016 issue of Gilroy Life

By Mark Turner

Mark Turner

Mark Turner

Listening to some of the proponents talk about Urban Growth Boundary Initiative, you would think the UGB will be a boon for Gilroy businesses and its residents. If a reduction in projected population (customers for local businesses), fewer jobs, more congested freeway traffic, less revenue for infrastructure improvements and higher rents equate to a boon, then you will have to agree with them. However, after reading the 9212 Report, which can be accessed on the city’s website, one can only come to the conclusion the UGB is bad for Gilroy.

Bad for Jobs

According to the 9212 Report, implementation of the UGB would result in a decline of more than 45 percent of potential jobs, labor income and economic output. With regard to construction, potential jobs, labor and economic output would decline by 30 percent.

Bad for Traffic

Traffic problems like those around Christopher High School will remain and will not be fixed since necessary road improvements in the area will be halted as the private investment mechanism for improvement is eliminated.
Fewer jobs in town will require more people on the road to pursue work. According to the 9212 report, because job numbers would likely decrease to a greater degree than population, implementation of the UGB would increase vehicle miles traveled. More traffic with less road improvements equates to more congestions, slower commute times and greater frustration.

Bad for Existing Businesses

The UGB “wall” that would be erected around Gilroy would limit the number of potential residents who contribute to the local economy. Businesses rely on residents to shop at their locations. Restaurants, retail, entertainment and small business owners would be greatly impacted by a decline in potential customers.

Bad for City Revenue

The 9212 Report indicates implementation of the UGB would decrease retail sales tax by about $1 million. Property tax revenue would be reduced by an estimated $3 million. General Fund Revenues would be reduced by nearly $9 million.

Bad for Infrastructure Improvements

Revenue to provide and maintain roads, parks and other essential services will diminish. With regard to deficient intersection level of service, the 9212 Report states, at existing deficient locations, intersections would continue to operate at unacceptable levels. Roadway extensions or improvements that would be needed outside the proposed UGB would be reduced. As growth diminishes so will Gilroy’s quality of life.

Bad for Renters

Amazingly, there are some people who don’t believe in the law of supply and demand with regard to the housing market and try to explain it away as a regional phenomenon. There is no denying when a product, such as rental units, are in high demand and there is less of that product available, higher prices will prevail. The same applies to real estate.

The potential for increased rent prices is a real threat. With 43 percent of Gilroyans renting, the financial impact to those families could be devastating.

There you have it: the bad and the ugly. There is no good in the proposed UGB Initiative for Gilroy and its residents.

Mark Turner is the president and CEO of the Gilroy Chamber of Commerce.