Published in the July 13-26, 2016 issue of Gilroy Life
By Dave Lima

Dave Lima
It’s natural for salespeople to want an unlimited variety of products in their portfolio to sell. So it’s no surprise that people who want employers to come to Gilroy want unlimited open space to offer to commercial and industrial developers. Most of us agree that bringing high-paying, lasting jobs to Gilroy is a top priority. Would unlimited land lure those employers to come to Gilroy? Probably not.
In 2015 a giant residential development project was proposed which required taking an inventory of vacant land already inside the city limits. That inventory, dated Nov. 18, 2015, showed that for the 10 years up to 2015 a total of 30.81 acres of land was approved for commercial development.
The inventory also tallied 135.21 acres of commercially-zoned land still available within the city limits. At the same rate of using up that land, there is more than 40 years worth of commercially zoned land still available in the city. This example shows that the simple availability of land is not what brings employers to Gilroy.
The fact is that land is already available for jobs development within the city limits. The proposed Urban Growth Boundary would enclose hundreds of additional acres of land zoned for jobs-creation that could be developed with no new development hassles at all.
And if that is not enough, if all that land were used up, the UGB measure would allow adding up to 50 acres per year for general industrial development. Let’s bring enough jobs to Gilroy to use up some of that land already inside the city limits before we complain about needing land outside the Urban Growth Boundary.
Another concern expressed by opponents of the UGB is that limiting residential housing sprawl will somehow raise housing prices. This is not logical. Historical evidence shows that this is not the case. Housing costs are overwhelmingly driven by regional economy swings, and not by small variations in the local supply of new homes. During the Great Recession between 2008 and 2013, home prices were generally depressed, even though few new homes were built.
There were low prices and no new construction. Now that we have thousands of new homes coming on the market in Glen Loma, Hecker Pass and Luchessa Avenue, home prices are going up, not down, because overall the economy is good. Now we have high prices and lots of construction. That’s just the opposite of what the opponents claim. You could even conclude that residential sprawl might raise home prices.
Supporters of the Urban Growth Boundary advocate compact development and smarter growth. This means focusing development on infill projects and building momentum in downtown. This emphasis on investing in the city we already have instead of bloating it with sprawling commuter housing is just plain smarter. Making our city services and water supply meet the needs of a compact city makes economic sense while also helping productive farmland and open space last longer. Keeping the city compact means that roads, sewers, street lighting, garbage collection, water supply, fire and police services and other city services are not extended and can be more efficient.
Thoughtful, creative planning and development of the land inside of the Urban Growth Boundary can make our city thrive economically and socially. It can help conserve our precious open space and farm land, encourage job creation over residential sprawl, conserve our water supply, and above all, it gives the people of Gilroy a direct vote on how big the city should get and how fast it should grow.
For more information visit www.gilroygrowingsmarter.org.
Dave Lima is the secretary of Gilroy Growing Smarter. He wrote this column for Gilroy Life.
Editor’s note: The Gilroy City Council voted unanimously July 5 to place the Gilroy Urban Growth Boundary initiative on the Nov. 8 general election ballot.
