Published in the February 8 – 21, 2017 issue of Gilroy Life

By Jennifer Barrera

Jennifer Barrera

Small businesses and job seekers will be hurt by an attempt to base a statewide law on a couple of local ordinances. AB 5 (Gonzalez Fletcher; D-San Diego/Kalra; D-San Jose) has been identified as a job killer by the California Chamber of Commerce because the bill mandates small employers with as few as 10 employees to offer all employees who have the skills and experience to perform additional hours of work that become available before hiring a new employee, temporary employee, or contractor.

A CalChamber analysis finds the bill limits employers’ ability to effectively manage their workforce to address both consumer and employee requests.

The bill will create unnecessary delays and burdens on small employers to accommodate employee and consumer demands, subject employers to costly fines and multiple avenues of litigation for technical violations that do not actually result in any harm to the employee, limit an employer’s ability to communicate truthful information, and reduce job opportunities for the unemployed.

Proposes Unnecessary Burdens on Small Employers

AB 5’s mandate for small employers to offer the additional hours of work to qualified current employees before looking outside the business creates a host of complications and concerns, including:

1. If an employer has facilities in different parts of the state, AB 5 mandates the employer to offer additional hours of work to employees in facilities where the employee does not work.

For example, under AB 5, an employer who has at least 10 employees throughout the state would have to contact employees in Southern California who have the skills and responsibilities to perform additional hours of work in Northern California, even though it is geographically unlikely the employee would be available to accept the additional hours of work. Requiring employers to go through this time-consuming exercise for all employees who have the skills and responsibilities to perform the work, but yet are unlikely to accept those hours for other reasons, such as physical location, creates unnecessary delay and limits an employer’s ability to respond to consumer demands and last-minute employee requests for time off.

2. AB 5 mandates an employer to contact each employee who has the skill and experience to perform the work required, even though that employee may have explicitly told the employer: a) the employee is not interested in additional hours of work; b) the employee is specifically unavailable on the day/time the additional hours are available; or c) while offering the additional hours of work to an employee at that time may not require overtime compensation, the additional hours of work added to the remaining scheduled shifts of that employee will require the employee to work overtime, thereby increasing the cost on an employer.

3. AB 5 fails to indicate what an employer actually has to do to satisfy the “offer” requirement of additional hours. Is a mass email distribution sufficient? Does the employer have to personally contact each employee? And, what happens if the employer cannot reach each employee? How long does the employer have to wait for a response from the employee before identifying which employee will receive the additional hours of work?

These unanswered questions will ultimately lead to litigation against the employer when an employee does not receive additional hours of work.

Jennifer Barrera works with the executive vice president in developing policy strategy and represents the California Chamber of Commerce on labor and employment, taxation and legal reform issues.