Measure H will ensure city services are not stretched to the limit

Published in the September 21 – October 4, 2016 issue of Gilroy Life

Dave Lima

Dave Lima

It’s time to get some facts straight about Measure H. It’s good for our local economy, it’s good for our local job growth, and it’s good for our future as a community.

Measure H is by Gilroyans for Gilroyans. It represents the will of hundreds of Gilroy citizens who contributed to the General Plan update process and want to see Gilroy grow and prosper. Measure H is a better bet to represent the will of the people than hoping four (out of seven) votes on the Gilroy City Council on any given Monday would actually follow the will of the people.

Measure H allows Gilroy voters to set Gilroy’s maximum size and shape to guide development through 2040 by establishing an Urban Growth Boundary. The UGB is a line on a map that shows the ultimate area where city growth can occur.

Measure H would allow for more than four times Gilroy’s predicted maximum job growth by 2040. Under Measure H there would be enough land to build businesses that could employ an additional 40,000 people or more. Experts employed by the city predicted that the most Gilroy could expect to attract by 2040 was 10,000 new jobs. The UGB has plenty of room for jobs.

Don’t be fooled by opponents of Measure H. We have plenty of land for job creation. Bringing jobs here depends on matching the jobs to the available labor force, access to raw materials and to markets, transportation and other infrastructure, and favorable permitting. Nothing about Measure H makes it harder to bring jobs to Gilroy.

Measure H is in line with Gilroy’s Residential Development Ordinance providing land for about 350 homes per year to be built. That’s about 8,000 new homes by the year 2040. With reasonable planning, this growth could be done with improved traffic flow and help solve some of our existing traffic problems, not make them worse. And slowing housing growth also slows down growing demand for precious water.

Measure H makes special accommodations for land for public facilities and industry. If special projects such as water or sewer construction, schools, parks, or affordable housing can’t be accomplished anywhere inside the UGB, the city council must locate them next to the UGB. The same applies to industrial projects up to 50 acres per year. This is one more way Measure H encourages responsible growth, rather than sprawling housing developments that we don’t need.

Measure H is predicted (by the city’s 9212 report) to cause a net surplus to Gilroy’s general fund, while actually growing the city’s income by about 45 percent by 2040. That’s because Measure H will ensure we don’t overstretch city services like sewer, water and roads. The average cost to Gilroy to provide services to a home is $220 per year more than the city receives in property taxes from that home. In contrast, taxes collected from an average business are far more than the business’ infrastructure costs.

Development impact fees are like a Ponzi scheme. They only pay for the initial cost of improvements. The long-term cost of infrastructure comes out of your pocket via the taxes you pay. Don’t be seduced by developers paying for new roads, sewers and schools, because the maintenance, upkeep and salaries all need to be paid for by the rest of us — forever.

Measure H is about long-term stability for our community. It’s about continuing to grow our sense of community in a way that reflects the values of our residents. It’s about strengthening the heart of our community by ensuring future city councils have firm parameters on where residents want growth to occur. It’s about being smart with our tax dollars.

Gilroy’s elected representatives need to address a host of issues facing our city, including the demand for affordable housing, downtown revitalization and traffic management. Measure H would not affect the city’s normal development processes, and it is not a substitute for inspired, responsible leadership and planning. Measure H is an important part of the solution, but it can’t fix all the problems we face.

Urban Growth Boundaries are not new and have been in place in many Bay Area cities for more than 20 years, including every city in Sonoma County. In some cities, such as Milpitas, Sebastopol and Petaluma, mayors and city councils are the strongest supporters of voter-approved UGBs. Those leaders have even campaigned to renew their UGBs because they have proven to help their cities prosper and maintain their unique identities. UGBs have helped those cities to attract new employers and jobs, protect open space, and focus development on their city cores to the benefit of all of their residents. We can do the same in Gilroy if we vote Yes on Measure H.

Dave Lima is treasurer of Gilroy Growing Smarter. He wrote this column for Gilroy Life.